5 Reasons Why Circle Time Is a Waste of Time at Preschool and Small Group Activities Are Better

Updated on December 19, 2017
letstalkabouteduc profile image

I'm a credentialed teacher with a master's degree in special education. I spent many years teaching preschool and kindergarten.

Circle Time Has Grown Longer and More Unwieldy

Each day across this great nation of ours young children gather on rugs, sitting quietly criss-cross applesauce, as their preschool teachers take center stage to conduct Circle Time. Circle Time is now an established part of the preschool day as the entire class assembles for various activities such as listening to stories, counting on the calendar, and doing show and tell. What, in heaven's name, you might wonder could be wrong with that.

As a former preschool and kindergarten teacher, I've seen Circle Time change over the years: becoming longer, more frequent, and quite unwieldy as teachers use it as their primary platform to educate young children. By relying too heavily on Circle Time, teachers are ignoring the research that shows young children benefit more from small group activities and open-play periods when they experiment, explore, and learn by doing. Circle Time is harmful when it's used instead of the more effective hands-on approach.

Small Group Activities and Hands-On Learning Are More Effective Than "Circle Time"

"Circle Time" is often a waste of time -- too long for young children to endure.
"Circle Time" is often a waste of time -- too long for young children to endure. | Source

Why Are Preschool Teachers Going Overboard With Circle Time Activities?

With research to the contrary, why then are preschool teachers doing longer and more frequent Circle Times you may wonder. Let's look at 5 reasons Circle Time is being used for all the wrong reasons:

1. Teachers Love to Be Center Stage at "Circle Time."

Have you ever attended a theatrical production where the actors on stage are having the time of their lives while the audience members sit in their seats – bored, frustrated, and wanting to bail? Go to any preschool to watch Circle Time and you'll probably see a similar state of affairs. Many preschool teachers --thwarted thespians at heart – use Circle Time as an opportunity to perform for a captive audience. Their young students – eager to wiggle, play, and talk – harness all their powers to sit quietly and listen passively.

A 4-year-old child's attention span is about 15 minutes according to child development experts. Therefore, 15 minutes is a reasonable duration for Circle Time at preschool (25-30 minutes is reasonable for kindergarten). However, it's common for teachers to conduct Circle Times that go on for 45 minutes to an hour. Because Circle Time is their favorite part of their jobs, teachers ignore children who are zoning out and continue with their theatrics.

Teachers Get to Shine During "Circle Time" But The Kids Are Bored

If only kids got as much from Circle Time as teachers do!
If only kids got as much from Circle Time as teachers do! | Source

2. Circle Time is Easy-Peasy Compared to Planning Small Group Activities.

According to the National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC), teachers should not expect youngsters to sit quietly for long periods at Circle Time. The NAEYC recommends teachers work with children individually and in small groups throughout the day, not just the entire class during Circle Time. In fact, many early childhood experts argue that small group instruction is one of the most effective but underused strategies at preschools. The NAEYC also recommends that youngsters use most of their time exploring materials and playing with other children, not sitting criss-cross applesauce as their teacher speaks.

Since these “best practices” are widely known and accepted, why do preschool teachers rely so heavily on Circle Time instruction? Quite frankly, it's because small group activities take more planning and effort than Circle Time activities, which are often repetitious (e.g. calendar and weather) or are “done on the fly” (e.g. going over classroom rules and talking about everyone's weekend fun).

At the preschool where I worked, teachers received an hourly wage for their classroom time but no compensation for the innumerable hours spent planning activities, preparing materials, and readying projects. Teachers like me put in unpaid time because we took pride in our work – wanting our classrooms to run smoothly and wanting the children to have happy, productive days. However, putting in hours and hours of work for no pay is unsustainable for most of us. That's one reason why the average annual turnover rate for childcare workers is 30 percent.

"Circle Time" Involves Repetitive Activities Such as Calendar and Weather. It Involves Little Preparation While Small Group Activities Require a Lot.

It takes time and effort to plan small group activities. Many preschool teachers aren't paid for that preparation.
It takes time and effort to plan small group activities. Many preschool teachers aren't paid for that preparation. | Source

3. Circle Time Activities Allow for a Higher Student-Teacher Ratio, Increasing Profits for the Preschool Owner.

Preschool owners love Circle Time for two reasons. First, Circle Time is peaceful, quiet, and orderly and parents get easily impressed by it. They're easily fooled into believing Circle Time is where the real learning takes place. Second, Circle Time allows for a higher student-teacher ratio. Teachers work with the entire group at once instead of moving from child to child or from small group to small group. Circle Time is like a college class in a lecture hall with as many bodies crammed in as possible.

The obvious difference being lectures are not a suitable strategy for teaching young children. Kids need hands-on experiences, facilitated instruction, cooperative learning projects, and plenty of time to play. All this is possible with lower student-teacher ratios.

Many preschool owners go above recommended ratios to increase revenue. The owner at the preschool where I worked would start in September with a reasonable ratio but continued to add children throughout the year. We'd often reach numbers too high for effective learning to take place while also compromising the safety of the children and the sanity of the teachers.

.According to the NAEYC, smaller group sizes and lower student-teachers ratios are a strong indicator of a strong program that promotes developmentally appropriate practices and values positive child-adult interactions. Classes that have children with special needs should have a lower student-teacher ratio.

"Circle Time" Is a Way to Put a Lot of Bodies in One Controlled Area

Preschool owners love Circle Time because it allows for higher teacher/student ratios, increasing revenue.
Preschool owners love Circle Time because it allows for higher teacher/student ratios, increasing revenue. | Source

The Decline of Play and the Rise of Mental Illness-- TEDTalks

4. Circle Time Costs Nothing.

Preschool owners are always trying to keep costs low. Their profit margins are often small with money going toward rent and salaries. They rarely have funds to cover teachers' extra expenses. Therefore, teachers use their own cash to buy fabric paint for Father's Day ties, pipe cleaners for tissue paper flowers, or goldfish for a science unit. Because the average wage for preschool teachers is only $11.95 an hour, it's understandable they don't want to shell out too much of their own hard-earned cash. Both owners and teachers love Circle Time because it costs absolutely nothing.

"Circle Time" Is Cost Effective for Preschools on a Tight Budget

Projects like these gingerbread kid costumes cost money and take a lot of preparation.
Projects like these gingerbread kid costumes cost money and take a lot of preparation. | Source

5. Parents Are Impressed by Circle Time, Not Play Time.

Parents are typically more impressed by Circle Time than any other activity at preschool. They watch the teacher take command of her class and feel a sense of comfort that a capable adult is in control. They feel their children are learning when spoon-fed information from the teacher.

Sadly, parents are least impressed during self-directed play time. Many parents see this as a waste of time as children explore materials, create open-ended art, and experience the joys and struggles of dealing with peers. Some ask: Why am I paying for this?

The well-informed parent, however, sees self-directed play as the most crucial part of the program – the time when youngsters learn how to solve problems, make choices, investigate deeply, and make friends. Circle Time accomplishes none of this.

Parents Get Too Easily Impressed by "Circle Time"

Some parents see self-directed play as a waste of time. They believe Circle Time is when the REAL learning takes place.
Some parents see self-directed play as a waste of time. They believe Circle Time is when the REAL learning takes place. | Source

Final Thoughts: Cutting Back on Circle Time

It's very easy to let Circle Time become the focus of the preschool day. When that happens, Circle Time is harmful. However, with a commitment to best practices in early childhood education, preschool owners and teachers can decrease whole group instruction. In the process, they can increase small group activities, open-play periods, and one-on-one instruction. This creates a healthier and happier environment where students gain initiative and independence while having fun and making friends.

Play  should not be rushed. Children need time to explore deeply.
Play should not be rushed. Children need time to explore deeply. | Source

Read This Book Before Choosing a Preschool for Your Child!

Taking Back Childhood: A Proven Roadmap for Raising Confident, Creative, Compassionate Kids
Taking Back Childhood: A Proven Roadmap for Raising Confident, Creative, Compassionate Kids

If you're a parent looking to get inspired and empowered, this is the book for you. There are so many forces out in the world robbing our children of their innocence and creativity – video games, cell phones, violent movies, commercialism – but this book shows us how to protect our youngsters from those influences. While everybody is over-programming their kids in sports, music lessons, and dance, this book talks about the value of down-time and imaginative play. I highly recommend parents of young children read this before choosing a preschool.


© 2015 McKenna Meyers


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • sybol profile image

      sybol 4 months ago

      I agree with Carol.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 4 months ago from Bend, OR

      Yes, that is definitely the type of Circle Time that gets a thumbs up from me. I'm so happy you're allowed to do this, Carol, and aren't pressured to do weather, calendar, patterns, etc. Too many preschool teachers must "prepare kids for kindergarten" with all kinds of information - letters, sounds, numbers, counting, sight words - and Circle Time has become the place to do it. It sounds like your talent and experience are appreciated and you're allowed to do what you know is right. Your students are lucky to have you. Thanks for commenting.

    • profile image

      Carol Garboden Murray 4 months ago

      I have been teaching for over 20 years and I've never done calendar time or weather charts. Circle time is always a gathering for songs and stories - a rich community building mid morning pause. Using our precious time for anything other than conversation, stories and songs is not an option. What a joyful gathering we enjoy every day!

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 4 months ago from Bend, OR

      We'll have to agree to disagree on this one, Sybol. Nobody has ever given me an adequate explanation of why Circle Time is beneficial for young children. Mostly, I hear that it prepares them for kindergarten because they must sit still and listen to the teacher. But, I strongly contend that the purpose of preschool is not to prepare little ones for elementary school. It's far more special and sacred than that. It's a time for kids to become active learners - explore and socialize. Thanks for adding your thoughts!

    • sybol profile image

      sybol 4 months ago

      I agree with some of your points and disagree with some. I don't think teachers are trying to be the center of attention when the have circle time. Sometimes circle time can be too long. 15 to 30 minutes is a good length of time for circle time. The key to circle time is engaging the children. You can tell when the children are interested and when you have lost their attention. Circle time should have a variety of activities which include movement and communication between the teacher and the children. I think circle time is beneficial.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 6 months ago from Bend, OR

      Yes, some preschool teachers are under a lot of pressure to prepare kids for kindergarten. Children are learning to read in kindergarten so now many preschools teach reading readiness (the alphabet, letter sounds) as well as math skills such as counting, number recognition, calendar, etc. I certainly don't think preschool teachers are lazy in any way, shape, or form - quite the opposite. I think they're expected to do too much for too little pay. Their primary goals must be to keep the kids safe and happy while facilitating exploration, play, and cooperation. The push for early learning is largely an American obsession. Other countries are more accepting of children's natural development. They enjoy kids at each unique stage and don't try to rush them to grow up faster and learn things sooner. I think we can learn a lot from that. Thanks for reading and commenting!

    • profile image

      Shelly 6 months ago

      I do agree, that group "circle" time should only be about 10 minutes long and that children learn more through play. I have to disagree with the fact that the reason teachers do longer circle times is because they want to be the center of attention, or because they are lazy and looking for the "easy peasy.. little preparation" way out. I honestly think it is a lack of education/understanding on what is appropriate as well as more and more pressure to bump down the curriculum and teach what used to be kindergarten in preschool.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 9 months ago from Bend, OR

      I agree. My older son had a fantastic preschool teacher who followed the principles of the NAEYC. She concluded the day with a short Circle Time (about 10 minutes) that promoted a sense of community. She sang and played a ukulele and the kids sang or danced. My younger son had a preschool teacher who was a former first grade teacher. She did a Circle Time that lasted an hour with a story, calendar activities, and sharing. It was way too long and the kids got bored. The parents, however, loved it because they thought it was preparing their kids for elementary school. Sadly, the focus of that preschool was on getting kids ready for kindergarten and not on enjoying the unique and magical experience of those early years -- promoting play and stimulating imagination. Thanks for commenting.

    • profile image

      If your children are finding circle boring and a was 9 months ago

      If your children are finding circle boring or a waste of time then shame on you! If you are a well educated ECE then you should be able to making a circle interactive and entertaining!!! You need to have spontaneous ways to have children be engaged, all children through music and movement,hands on, etc. Many time teachers in this field become lazy and not dedicated to their profession.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 17 months ago from Bend, OR

      Thanks for the kind words, Becky. A truly talented preschool teacher shines during self-directed play -- making sure everyone is involved and happy, posing questions that make the children stop and think, inspiring them to try something new. It's definitely the most important part of the preschool day, but some parents don't get it. They think: My child can play at home. At school I want them to learn. To these parents, learning only happens when the teacher is imparting information to the kids in a structured way. It's very hard to change their minds on that.

    • Becky Callahan profile image

      Rachel Finlay 17 months ago

      Excellent and informative article! I am from a family of teachers and have heard some of these points echoed. I had not considered your point that parents see self directed play as more chaotic and possibly a waste of time, so they may view circle time as more controlled and effective. Great perspective!

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 21 months ago from Bend, OR

      Well said Pelim 50. Talented and experienced teachers in early childhood education are considered "old-fashioned" with their talk about the importance of play and hands-on learning. Unfortunately, parents are easily tempted by structured teacher-led activities that will give their children a "competitive edge" such as STEM lessons, a second language, formal art instruction and, as you mentioned, worksheets and workbooks. Those who make the big decisions know little about child development.

    • profile image

      pelim50 21 months ago

      In 30 years teaching, preschool was always fun for me. Watching children exploring their world during play and working in small groups was essential in my room. The parents always confirmed how much their children learned. At one point my work place downsized and I lost my job.

      On my search for a new job I had to leave 2 jobs already because I couldn't agree with their work ethic of putting 20 children into circletime for over an hour and have them do 2-3 first grade level worksheets right after. Gave us about an hour for snack and a craft...

      I was told they expected me to hold that high end learning standart in this room.

      Playdough did not excist and the teachers put the toys out the kids were allowed to play. It was super clean and organized but had no time for exploring anything else.

      When I tried changing things the children loved it but I got in trouble in no time. My assistent didnt agree with me at all, just ignored my daily plan and kept the old routine by just being faster than me instructing the kids what to do...

      I felt like I was failing on the kids and I felt like in a cage.

      I had no support from supervisors because they were afraid of a "messy" room.

      I just think times are changing and I count to those "old fashioned" teachers.

      It is sad to read this great article which I completely agree with but the reality is so much different...

    • Kathryn L Hill profile image

      Kathryn L Hill 2 years ago from LA

      Childhood is a happy time. People need to remember what made them happy as kids! : -)

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 2 years ago from Bend, OR

      Thanks, Kathryn. I'll check those out. I think Montessori and Waldorf have a lot to offer.

    • Kathryn L Hill profile image

      Kathryn L Hill 2 years ago from LA

      Maria Montessori has a lot to contribute toward enlightenment regarding the truth about children through her books, The Secret of Childhood and The Absorbent Mind.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 2 years ago from Bend, OR

      Yes, some kids get very adept at zoning out during school and many teachers don't mind as long as they're not disruptive. While I understand zoning out in a boring college lecture, I think it's sad when little kids zone out during preschool. Preschool should be fun, stimulating, and interactive, not boring. Thanks for reading and commenting!

    • Dolores Monet profile image

      Dolores Monet 2 years ago from East Coast, United States

      When my youngest son attended pre-school and kindergarten, I used to watch him during circle time. After sitting there for awhile, I could see that he began to zone out. Worried, I soon realized that he was not the only one. That zoning out while being trapped in a boring circle can create a mind that zones out throughout the school years when the child become bored with a long session of idleness.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 2 years ago from Bend, OR

      Thanks for reading! Yes, there's incredible stuff going on in preschools and many gifted teachers making a difference. Unfortunately, the high turnover rate among teachers makes it difficult to maintain excellence. Being a preschool teacher can be a dead-end job with no way to rise through the ranks and no way to make more money.

    • ologsinquito profile image

      ologsinquito 2 years ago from USA

      Very interesting. I agree that some teachers definitely take the easy way out. Free play is very important for typical children. Some of the special education children may need a bit more direction though. I've seen some wonderful preschools and one very poorly run classroom that should have been shut down. Eventually I think someone stepped in.

    • letstalkabouteduc profile image

      McKenna Meyers 2 years ago from Bend, OR

      Thanks for your supportive comments. Small group work and cooperative learning projects were en vogue when I got my teaching credential 25 years ago. Sadly, there's little emphasis on them today.

    • aparker1988 profile image

      Amber 2 years ago

      I love this article. I actually wrote a paper about something similar for one of my college classes. Sugata Mitra won the Ted award for his really cool idea of small group learning with a computer. His plan is to have a class run totally off the cloud and each small group of 5 or 6 kids has a topic. Something deep like "what caused the dinosaurs to go extinct?" so that they can't just google it once and find the answer. Your article is about preschool and Mitra's idea is for older grade school kids. I think the idea that small group learning that is child-led is a great idea and if I were an educator, I would definitely approach it this way. As it is, I'm not! Great article!