Skip to main content

Common Sinkholes in a Blended Family Dynamic

With two of her own, Denise remarried and brought two children from her husband together to explore what it means to be a blended family.


My Blended Family

When we married, my husband had two children from a previous marriage, and I had two children from a previous marriage. That’s a conflict by a factor of 4, and believe me, we felt it nearly every day. However, we also had the joy of watching all of them grow and become a loving family together. We had good times and bad. All the laughing and all crying happened there.

Encountering Sinkholes

Here in California, there have been a number of droughts. Each time that happens, especially here in the Central Valley, we rely on groundwater. As the groundwater is depleted and never really replenished, there have been many places where whole towns are sinking. Sinkholes open up totally unexpectedly and swallow cars or even whole houses. That’s what can happen in blended families without warning.

Because my husband and I fell into the sinkholes along the way, we know where some of them are located and have dedicated our lives to helping other blended families avoid as many as possible. Here are a few of the common sinkholes you may want to avoid:

  1. Quarrels
  2. Angry Child Sabotage
  3. Birth Order Dynamic

Along the way, I also learned the value of using different types of love language for my family and children and even some red flags to keep an eye out for to prepare myself for these sinkholes.




Quarrels happen in and around parenting issues and styles, and when the kids hear their names mentioned in a loud exchange, they can’t help but think they caused it. This is only one of the many reasons that you should keep conflict concerning the parenting issues to a minimum if at all possible. At least you should keep it out of the children’s earshot.

Also, voices raise and sound carries much better than you would think, so having an exchange, heated or not, should happen as far from the children as you can make humanly possible. My husband and I would often take walks to discuss an issue like how to deal with one or more of the children’s behavior problems, whenever the weather permitted.

But more often than not, we would have an exchange right there in front of the kids without knowing it was going to blow up into a full-fledged argument. We failed so often I don’t want to think about it. What it did to the kids was to put them on edge. They were confused and angry. They would usually take sides and have fights with the stepsiblings, and it became a “your dad, my mom” kind of thing.

Family means putting your arms around each other and being there.

— Barbara Bush



The Angry Child Sabotage

In the meantime, I have seen an angry child do things that will wreck a second marriage. They can make up stories about the new stepparent and set up situations that sabotage the whole relationship if you aren’t aware of what’s happening. And the children aren’t evil or really overly mean. They just haven’t subconsciously accepted this new relationship and don’t want to see that it can be for the best.

Often I remember my oldest daughter would have a really great day with us all at some outing (herself, her sister, me and my new husband, and two step-siblings) and the next day she was an absolute terror. Moody, bitter, vindictive, spouting hateful words to everyone. Later we realized that she had had such a wonderful time that she forgot her biological father wasn’t even there, and later that night punished herself for having a good time without him. The next day she punished us as well. This is more typical than I care to say.

Sometimes good resources can lift you out of the sinkholes.

Sometimes good resources can lift you out of the sinkholes.

Birth Order Dynamic

The studies show, and I can testify, that typically it will be the oldest who has the biggest problem with the new blended family situation. Perhaps it is because he or she feels a loyalty to the absent parent; perhaps it is because they are old enough to remember the family before it broke up. Either way, the oldest will not want to accept this new family dynamic.

If they do feel good or accepting about it, they typically will feel guilty or even disloyal for feeling that way. This causes the oldest to want to act out, set up family disturbances or fights amongst the others, sometimes without even know that they are doing it. It is incredibly hard to keep things fair and balanced in the blended family situation but this dynamic will add extra stress.

How to Handle the Oldest Child

The best thing to do is to take him or her away from the rest occasionally, talk intelligently with them and assure them you understand that they miss the absent parent. Ask how they are doing with the others and with school or other stressors. Remember, a child has a hard time articulating feelings. They know they feel deeply but don’t always know why or know how to tell you about it.

I remember one summer when my oldest was told in a letter that her father was coming to see them during the summer. As I look back now, I realize she placed herself near the window in the living room all summer so that she would be the first to see him driving up the driveway. When school began in September she completely melted down, throwing things, yelling and refusing to go to school. When I got her alone she finally was able to say that school starting meant that the summer was officially over and her father had not come.

This is so difficult for children. She wasn’t mad at me or the other members of the family, but we were there and her father was not. Don’t be too surprised if you are on the receiving end of blow-ups that are not really about you.

Resources to pull you out of that hole.

Resources to pull you out of that hole.

Love Languages

Find your child’s love language.

I did find Gary Chapman’s 5 Love Languages to be of great help when finding why some things made my kids (and my spouse) excited while others didn’t. Those love languages came in real handy when leaving little chocolates on pillows and sharing chores. It is well worth the time to read, believe me.

Red Flags

Now I feel like a roadside flagman, waving my red flag at newly remarried couples to say, “the bridge is out ahead. Go carefully.” Or more likely, “Storm’s a’coming. Take shelter.” I don’t think I would have changed my course or not married if I had known the problems ahead. If only I had had a flagman to let me know the potholes were so deep I would at least have been less surprised or at least braced when I fell into it. So for those of you, like me, who are going to make this jump or who already have, careful . . . deep potholes ahead!

Families are the compass that guide us. They are the inspiration to reach great heights, and our comfort when we occasionally falter.

— Brad Henry

My mad mushroom fairy.

My mad mushroom fairy.

Final Thoughts

There are so many more sinkholes I could mention but it would take volumes to list them all. The truth is that each family is different and each child will react to the blended family dynamic differently. Also, there are seasons where everything seems sunny, followed by a season of storms. Whatever your season, I wish you calm in the storm and a reminder that this too will pass. If you have any problems you’d like to discuss with me I’d love to hear from you in the comments below.

Play plenty of games!

Play plenty of games!

This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.


Denise McGill (author) from Fresno CA on February 28, 2021:

Linda Lum,

I like to think we have the magic potion! Humans ARE so complex, you are so right. These little humans put me through a lot of changes but once I tried to get into their point of view, I could understand them better. Thanks for commenting.



Linda Lum from Washington State, USA on September 01, 2019:

Denise, children, even at a very young age, are more perceptive than we give them credit for. They can sense the tension when there is conflict. But at the same time, they have difficulty expressing their emotions. Human being are so complex! Thank you for sharing your experiences. It's obvious that you and your mate had the magic potion that makes it work--love.

Denise McGill (author) from Fresno CA on September 01, 2019:

Lorna Lamon,

Yes, it was difficult and most of the time my husband and I felt so clueless. There was little to no help out there at the time and our church didn't want to touch the subject in fear of "endorsing" divorce. We felt very alone. After figuring out where we went wrong so often we decided to write on the subject and start our own support group in our church. We found that we weren't alone and there were lots of parents going through similar situations. Now with the internet people at least have someplace to turn for information. Thanks for commenting.



Lorna Lamon on September 01, 2019:

Hi Denise, Such a well thought out article and coming from your own personal experiences this information is invaluable. I can only imagine how difficult these situations can be with so many emotions at play - definitely challenging but also extremely rewarding.