My rule with my kids is that if they are doing their best, I will help them. If you want to give her the car, keep the title and give her a month to get a job. If after a month she isn't making progress, take the car back. Also, I would have her pay you for the car, look up the book value on Kelly Blue book, do a contract. You can even file as lien holder on the title which gives you the right to take the car if she doesn't pay. The other option is not to give her the car. The choice is yours.