Girl Scout Alternatives - WeHaveKids - Family
Updated date:

Girl Scout Alternatives

Tamara Wilhite is a technical writer, industrial engineer, mother of two, and published sci-fi and horror author.

What are the alternatives to the Girl Scouts? Which programs offer your daughter the same experience of joining a troop, earning merit badges, growing as a leader, and performing community service as scouts outside of Girl Scouts? Conversely, which programs give your daughter a place to socialize with her peers or further her faith outside of Sunday School?

This article provides a synopsis of several Girl Scout alternatives, listed in alphabetical order, as well as information on each.

My daughter is in American Heritage Girls or AHG.

My daughter is in American Heritage Girls or AHG.

Summary of Girl Scout Alternatives

ProgramOpen to Boys?Complementary Program for Boys




American Heritage Girls


Faith Based Boys

Frontier Girls Club



Girls in Action


Royal Ambassadors

International Order of the Rainbow for Girls


DeMolay International

Knights of Columbus Squire Roses


Knights of Columbus Squires




Pioneer Club



National Girls Ministries/Missionettes


Royal Rangers



Alert Cadet


AWANA is a Christian Bible study program for children two through high school. AWANA is well known because it is over sixty years old. Awana has separate programs for preschoolers, elementary school children, middle school and high school students. AWANA lessons may be incorporated in Sunday School programs or used as youth program. AWANA is non-denominational.


  • Awana - Home
    Training to help Awana leaders, pastors and youth and childrens ministry workers evangelize and disciple kids for Christ.

American Heritage Girls

American Heritage Girls or AHG started as a girls’ complementary program to the Boy Scouts. AHG is a growing alternative to the Girl Scouts, complete with merit badges, workbooks, activities and camping opportunities. American Heritage Girls is open to girls ages 5 through 18.

As of yet, American Heritage Girls does not have its own campgrounds, but many troops go camping in state and national parks.

AHG split from the Boy Scouts in 2013 due to its acceptance of homosexual boys in its ranks. American Heritage Girls is now the companion organization for the Faith Based Boys.

American Heritage Girls

Frontier Girls Club

Frontier Girls Club is a small program similar to the Girl Scouts. They have an organized program teaching life skills, community service and leadership. Groups can go camping, though they don’t have facilities in their own right. (Nothing stops a troop from going to the local state park to camp, though.)

Frontier Girls Club is notable for having a program for preschoolers, whereas most similar programs wait until kids start school. They also have a level for girls over 18 who want to participate.

They don’t have a boys-only program, but they have a co-ed program called Quest Clubs.

Frontier Girls Club

Girls in Action

Girls in Action is the girls’ complementary program for the Southern Baptist Royal Rangers program. Girls in Action or GA is intended for girls aged 9 through 16. The girls are sometimes called Missionettes. Younger girls are included in the Baptist Children in Action program.

Girls in Action has its own magazine, GA World, which is published bi-weekly.

International Order of the Rainbow for Girls

The International Order of the Rainbow for Girls or Rainbow for short is a girls’ organization within the Masonic lodge program. Rainbows range in age from 11 to 20. The organization focuses on community service. If you are interested in joining Rainbows, contact your local Masonic lodge. Membership is not limited to family members of existing Masons.

Knights of Columbus Squire Roses

The Knights of Columbus is a stalwart organization for Catholic men. The Knights of Columbus Squire Roses is their program for girls aged 10 through 18. There are fewer Squire Rose circles than groups for boys. If you are interested in joining this Christian women’s organization, contact your local parish.

Another Girl Scout alternative for Catholics is Little Flowers Girls' Club, but they are not as widespread as the Knights of Columbus.

Knights of Columbus Squires and Squire Roses

  • Knights of Columbus Home Page
    This is the home page for the Knights of Columbus Squires. Contact the local Circle to find out if there is a Squire Rose Circle in your parish.


The Seventh Day Adventist church runs the Pathfinders, a group open to both boys and girls. Pathfinders has merit badges and a green uniform similar to that of the Girl Scouts. The Pathfinders program is open to children from fifth grade through twelfth grade.

Pathfinders Homepage

Pioneer Club

The Pioneer Club is a unisex organization for children aged two through fourteen. The Pioneer Club is similar to AWANA in that it can be run as a Sunday school program or as a youth program like Scouts. It is non-denominational but strongly Protestant.

The Pioneer Club has several summer camps in the United States and Canada.

Pioneer Club Home Page

National Girls’ Ministries

National Girls Ministries are specific to the Assemblies of God denomination. They have activities for girls from preschool through high school.

The companion program for boys, the Royal Rangers, is for boys in kindergarten through twelfth grade.

National Girls Ministries

STEP by Alert Cadet

Skills Training for Emergency Preparedness or STEP is a four week preparedness program for girls 15 and up. STEP teaches skills in wilderness survival and builds leadership. STEP is offered by the creators of the Alert Cadet program for boys. STEP Advanced covers topics from wilderness survival to Bible study to rock climbing.

Related Articles


Conservative Boy Scout Alternatives

There are a number of conservative Boy Scout alternatives—which one is right for you?

Tip: Leave electronics at home.  Squirrels and mice love nut-sized earbuds from iPods!

Secrets to Successful Girl Scout Encampments

Winning tips for a great Girl Scout encampment.


What Is the Correct Placement for Girl Scout Badges?

Learn where Girl Scout badges, patches, and pins should go on a vest or sash, and discover why they go there.


Girl Scout Bridging

A bridging ceremony in Girl Scouts symbolizes moving to another level of Scouting. Daisies to Brownies, Brownies to Juniors, Juniors to Cadettes . . . .


Girl Scout Daisy Event Ideas

Get some ideas for a successful Daisy Day with fun events for first-year Daisy Girl Scouts.


Daisy Girl Scouts: Earning the Respect Authority Petal

Ideas to engage girl scouts as they learn what it means to respect authority and earn their magenta daisy petal


How to Go Camping With Your Girl Scout Troop

Camping with your Girl Scout troop builds memories and helps girls grow into leaders who love the outdoors. Teach girls how to plan their own trip.


Camping Tips For Girl Scout Trips

Tips for successful Girl Scout camping. Includes a useful leader's gear list.

A basic informational flyer and registration sheet. This one doesn't have Service Project information on it.  You should include Service information, especially if each troop is supposed to bring something to the event.

Girl Scouts World Thinking Day Event Planning

How to plan a Girl Scouts World Thinking Day event with your troop or Service Unit without too much stress.


Daisy Girl Scouts: Earning the Friendly and Helpful Petal

Ideas to engage girls as they learn how to be friendly and helpful.


Girl Scout Wide Game to Celebrate Juliette Low's Birthday

Learn how to organize a Girl Scout wide game. A fun wide game for any event, but an especially good game event to celebrate Juliette Low's birthday.


Girl Scout Swaps - the What, Why and How.

A swap is a small handmade craft that scouts exchange with each other. Usually handmade, they include a pin for storage and often include information about the givers troop or location.


19 Cub Scout Skits

Cub Scout skits are fun to do. Below you will find my favorite skits that are suitable for Cub Scouts, Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, Brownies, and any other camp setting.


The Boy Scout Oath Explained

Anyone familiar with the Boy Scouts will recognize the Scout Law and the Scout Oath. But what is a Boy Scout pledging when he recites the Scout Oath? Here is the Scout Oath broken down and explained.


Daisy Girl Scouts: Earning the Courageous and Strong Petal

Ideas to engage girls as they learn to be courageous and strong.